|
|
Confirmed that some hadith is not reliable claimed by muslims
[Copy link]
|
|
|
did not u sound like dumb now? did not u ask
--------------
Your question not completed man. please check the phrase.
u didn't know such paradise in muslims has weddings?? is that diff cult for u understand or u trying to avoid because u are embarrassed?
--------------
never heard of it.. where did you refer? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
nice2000 This user has been deleted
|
|
so apa maksud awk yang sebenarnya....sy x faham solan awk............. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Truth.8 at 28-9-2006 02:41 PM
u mean never about it? yet u trying to be smart here and jugding the Bible??
ler, its what u have said before, "one pointing at others, while ur 4 fingers pointing back at u"
and what are u doing now?? judging the al-quran and the hadith |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by nice2000 at 28-9-2006 02:49 PM
itu mengikut kata2 orang islam yang x kenal islam yang sebenar lagi........klu nak tahu yang sebenar kenalah rujuk yang betul ok...seperti pak imam yang bertauliah........begitu juga kristian x semuanye arif pasal kristian......jawapannya hadis wajib di percayai jika ia sohih(yang membawa maksud ucapan yang keluar dari nabi Muhammad Rasullullah s.a.w) jika ia bukan datang dari muhammad s.a.w maka ia kena merujuk kepada al-quran terlebih dahulu.....kerana al-quran ayat dari Allah S.W.T.........
dan al-quran x sama mcm bible.........kerana ia datang dari allah segala ayat2 yang terkandung didalam itu ...
So, u sayings some of the statements from muslims in this forum here is not Islam? another great confusion via contradiction.
?..and Bible is not like Koran because Bible comes from True God and True God do not need his peoples to create another book like hadith because we already has one source which is Bible because true God is not great master of deceiver who gives confusion to us by sayings hadith is ok and some says not ok?..that is great confusion that create by satan the devil.
no wonder why satan give confusion but also allowed blood shed among ur muslims by burning mosques. everything seems to be good in surface but once we exposed the truth, u musims trampled |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by i212 at 28-9-2006 02:52 PM
never heard of it.. where did you refer?
U mean never heard that there is a weddings in islam paradise once u all dah mampos and di bangkitkan? How come u like make judgment on Bible but u are lack of knowledge in Islam? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by dak_ker at 28-9-2006 03:02 PM
ler, its what u have said before, "one pointing at others, while ur 4 fingers pointing back at u"
and what are u doing now?? judging the al-quran and the hadith
did we called ur koran porno? so who started first? for such small question i create u muslims trampled , can u muslims handled my another thread on " why i left islam?
in this topic is not ponit finger but we talking with fact why some muslims do not trust hadith?? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Truth.8 at 28-9-2006 03:12 PM
can u muslims handled my another thread on " why i left islam?
its u who cannot handle ur own thread, y u not answering all of the questions that they have asked????
im wondering..
Originally posted by Truth.8 at 28-9-2006 03:12 PM
in this topic is not ponit finger but we talking with fact why some muslims do not trust hadith??
keh keh keh, mengata dulang paku serpih, mengata orang dia yg lebih :lol :lol :lol |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by dak_ker at 28-9-2006 03:24 PM
its u who cannot handle ur own thread, y u not answering all of the questions that they have asked????
im wondering..
keh keh keh, mengata dulang paku serpih, mengata orang dia yg leb ...
they asking repeating question and not worth replying and cari server is quite slow and it taking my time as well.
for example the issue of Sabbath, Gay and few other question ....all this already rebuked. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
There are three types of Hadiths,
(1) Qudsi Hadiths which are the words of God link to the Quran but are not part of the Quran.
(2) Nabawi Hadiths which are narrations by or about our prophet saw
(3) Plain Hadiths which are narrations by and about other than our prophet saw
No. 3 type is not subject to the rigorous and stringent rules of authentication and many of them are not valid even if they are in Bukhari抯.
And most anti-muslims took No. 3 to bash Islam. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
So, u sayings some of the statements from muslims in this forum here is not Islam? another great confusion via contradiction.
----------------
TWISTERRRRRR.... She/he talk in MALAY.
Some Not Reliable means = Sesetengahnya diragui. = hadis wajib di percayai jika ia sohih
sohih = reliable
Jika ia bukan datang dari muhammad s.a.w maka ia kena merujuk kepada al-quran terlebih dahulu.....kerana al-quran ayat dari Allah S.W.T.........
Same like we said. if have doubt on Hadith, Refer the Quran first.
UNDERSTAND?
?..and Bible is not like Koran because Bible comes from True God and True God do not need his peoples to create another book like hadith because we already has one source which is Bible because true God is not great master of deceiver who gives confusion to us by sayings hadith is ok and some says not ok?..that is great confusion that create by satan the devil.
---------------------------
HEHEHEHE.... THATS WHY HAVE 101 CONTRADICTIONS? AND CONFUSE ABOUT TRINITY OR NOT?
SOME SAY TRINITY, SOME SAY NOT. EVEN THEY CAN CHANGE THE CONTAIN.
THE MAIN POINT IS,
YOU COMPARE BIBLE WITH HADITH.
ITS MEAN YOU AGREE BIBLE ARE MIX OF HUMAN WORDS BECAUSE
HADITH FOR MUSLIM ARE HUMAN WORD. CAN HAVE DOUBT AND NEED TO ANALYZED.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
well, if it's the truth, it's a dumb statement, why should i say otherwise, just to be nice and to be hypocrite? my religion does not teach me to be a hypocrite, truth.8. not sure about yours then. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The true faith always depend on one source which is The Bible. Why? Because God do not want us to confused with many source of saying this and that. If one were to read the Bible, it contains future events of prophecy, good conduct, healthy diet meat to be eaten and etc.
If Islam indeed true religion , Muslims should asked "Why they need hadith "? or are they lack in trusting koran which need two source to depend ?
Where else the Bible is complete and Koran is not complet because they still need to depend the hadith.
....but too bad some muslims view some hadith is not relliable.
This what great confusion that satan has drawn muslims to their religion.
When God says "Keep my Sabbath Holy" satan comes in cunning tactic "no , because sabbath is for jews" as satan can masquerade as angel of light to misleads all souls in this world.
Satan tactic is simple, just come in and provide systematical religion which look good
Muslims should think and repent before too late. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Truth.8 at 28-9-2006 03:28 PM
they asking repeating question and not worth replying and cari server is quite slow and it taking my time as well.
for example the issue of Sabbath, Gay and few other question ....all this a ...
alahai Truth 8,
awak yg asking repeating question, awak tak sedar ..
pity u .. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
in this topic is not ponit finger but we talking with fact why some muslims do not trust hadith??
--------------------------------
See post #29. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by LostSoul at 28-9-2006 03:34 PM
well, if it's the truth, it's a dumb statement, why should i say otherwise, just to be nice and to be hypocrite? my religion does not teach me to be a hypocrite, truth.8. not sure about yours then.
u wrote that some hadith is not reliable? are u denying now?? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
hmmmm if i said u r dumb, then you get angry, emotional. but take a look at your statement again, where did i say that i deny my earlier statement??? no wonder you are what you are...
case closed. arguing with you is like arguing with an adult with the brain of 5 years old. at least the brain of 5 year old is young, fresh, and can be moulded, yours is over and done with. surely yours full with loopholes nad looks like a maze. duhh |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by dome at 28-9-2006 03:29 PM
1) Qudsi Hadiths which are the words of God link to the Quran but are not part of the Quran.
(2) Nabawi Hadiths which are narrations by or about our prophet saw
(3) Plain Hadiths which are narrations by and about other than our prophet saw
No. 3 type is not subject to the rigorous and stringent rules of authentication and many of them are not valid even if they are in Bukhari抯.
And most anti-muslims took No. 3 to bash Islam.
...
Even the 3 plain hadith not reliable, why it market world wide?? why still need 1,2,3 hadith? that show ur koran is incomplete. The Bible do not need such 1,2,3 saying of hadith because we believed the Bible is complete book for our guidance.
read here:
The true faith always depend on one source which is The Bible. Why? Because God do not want us to confused with many source of saying this and that. If one were to read the Bible, it contains future events of prophecy, good conduct, healthy diet meat to be eaten and etc.
If Islam indeed true religion , Muslims should asked "Why they need hadith "? or are they lack in trusting koran which need two source to depend ?
Where else the Bible is complete and Koran is not complete because they still need to depend the hadith.
....but too bad some muslims view some hadith is not reliable.
This what great confusion that satan has drawn muslims to their religion.
When God says "Keep my Sabbath Holy" satan comes in cunning tactic "no , because sabbath is for jews" as satan can masquerade as angel of light to misleads all souls in this world.
Satan tactic is simple, just come in and provide systematical religion which look good
Muslims should think and repent before too late. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by LostSoul at 28-9-2006 03:45 PM
hmmmm if i said u r dumb, then you get angry, emotional. but take a look at your statement again, where did i say that i deny my earlier statement??? no wonder you are what you are...
case closed. arguing with you is like arguing with an adult with the brain of 5 years old. at least the brain of 5 year old is young, fresh, and can be moulded, yours is over and done with. surely yours full with loopholes nad looks like a maze. duhh
this what u wrote:Originally posted by LostSoul at 28-9-2006 01:11 PM
well, what they said is true. some hadiths are not reliable. !!!
....and you twiste 360 degreed by sayings i am 5 yrs old child which is of course u parroting from other muslims who says the same thing. just like the person refuse admit that he/she also rude and no respect. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Even the 3 plain hadith not reliable, why it market world wide?? why still need 1,2,3 hadith? that show ur koran is incomplete.
--------------
See... you show that u r dumb about islam but want to Bash Islam.
Those 3 not the name of hadith. Its the Category.
HADITH CONTAINED WHAT PROPHET MUHAMMAD DAILY PREACHES, ACTIVITY, WHAT HE DO AND WHAT HE DO NOT. ITS CONTAIN MEANING ATAU "HURAIAN" AL-QURAN VERSES.
HADITH IS NOT PART OF AL-QURAN BUT HADITH CONTAINS PART OF AL-QURAN MEANING.
ITS CONTAIN ALL ADDITIONAL UNDERSTANDING, PURPOSELY FOR PEOPLE LIKE YOU THAT JUST READ AND TAKE THE VERSE WITHOUT THINKING MATURELY.
The Bible do not need such 1,2,3 saying of hadith because we believed the Bible is complete book for our guidance
------------------------
THATS WHY CHRISTIANS CONFUSE WITH THEIR BELIEVE. GOD ARE TWO? GOD ARE THREE?
THATS WHY THERE ARE CONTRADICTIONS. AND CHRISTIANS JUST BELIEVE WHAT THEIR PRIEST SAID.
Where else the Bible is complete and Koran is not complete because they still need to depend the hadith.
---------------
WE NOT DEPEND ON HADITH. HADITH ARE ADDITIONAL INFO. WE DEPEND ON QURAN.
When God says "Keep my Sabbath Holy" satan comes in cunning tactic "no , because sabbath is for jews" as satan can masquerade as angel of light to misleads all souls in this world.
------------
AGAIN.... THE SABBATH THING. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
tsk tsk pity... lack of comprehension, emotional, people said someting else, you misunderstood it and shout back to the world the wrong thing. no words left from me for you truth.8, just pity... tsk tsk too bad, so sad... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
Post time 28-9-2006 02:52 PM
Author
